Skip to main content

Organization: Law Society of Alberta

Blank petition form with tip of fountain pen above signature line

Elections Alberta begins verifying independence petition

Elections Alberta began verifying signatures July 6 on a citizen initiative petition seeking a referendum on Alberta independence, with results due by July 27.

The petition, titled A Referendum Relating to Alberta Independence, proposes the question “Do you agree that the Province of Alberta should cease to be a part of Canada to become an independent state?”

Verification began following a June 29 Court of Appeal decision.

Proponent Mitch Sylvestre submitted the signature sheets May 4, but the process was put on hold — first through a stay issued by the Court of King’s Bench, then a decision that quashed the petition.

Sylvestre appealed and the Court of Appeal issued a partial stay requiring Elections Alberta to proceed with verification and report the results, effective July 6.

To succeed, the petition needs valid signatures from at least 10 per cent of the total votes cast in the 2023 provincial general election or 177,732 signatures. Elections Alberta has 21 days to verify the petition to a 95 per cent confidence level, using a method set out in the Citizen Initiative Act.

Verification includes confirming that only official signature sheets were used, that signatures are original and signed only once, that each carries the required elector information, and that each was witnessed by a registered canvasser.

Elections Alberta will also check a statistically valid random sample of signatories’ addresses and contact a random sample of signatories to confirm their information.

An older couple smiles while leaning on a wooden railing outdoors, above text describing their $879 profit share from Vision Credit Union and a website link.

Those who listed a phone number will receive a text message ahead of a verification call; those who listed an email will receive a verification email. Elections Alberta says there is no need to call or text back, and electors who signed should be prepared to verify their information if contacted.

Chief Electoral Officer Gordon McClure notified both the proponent and the minister of justice of the verification dates, times and location. Both may request scrutineers (lawyers and active members of the Law Society) to observe.

It is the second citizen initiative petition Elections Alberta has verified this summer, following the Water Not Coal petition, which fell short of the signature threshold July 3.

Elections Alberta will post the verification results on its website as soon as practical, and no later than July 27. If the petition is successful, Elections Alberta will submit the proposal to the minister of justice, who is required under the Citizen Initiative Act to refer it toward a constitutional referendum.

More information on the citizen initiative process is available at elections.ab.ca.

Alberta Independence | Separation, Citizen Initiative Act, Citizen Initiative Petitions, Elections | Referendums, Water Not Coal Petition

Three white envelopes blow in the wind in front of an open grey mailbox on the heading for Shootin' the Breeze Mailbox articles and letters to the editor.

Opinion: Rules for thee, but not for me, on citizen petitions

Submission from Allan Garbutt, Cowley

 

Let me get this straight.

Our premier and her government claim to believe in direct democracy. That is, they will do what the people ask them to do. The citizen petitions and subsequent referendums seem to be an example of this.

For those items that do not generate petitions, I presume the government will use their opinion polls to determine where the voters stand on various issues. Then, they can take those positions to referendums as well. Or, at least they can pass laws that reflect the sentiment uncovered in the various surveys.

Reality looks a bit different.

Few Albertans appear to want an Alberta Pension Plan. At least that’s what I take from the numbers various journalists ultimately pried out of the mislabelled black box called Freedom of Information — not!

But, we are going to have a chance to vote on both issues in October. After, I might add, the government has had several months to put out their views on the issues. Anyone opposed to the government view will, of course, have to fund their own campaign.

I do not know anyone who understands how the government can run ads in Ontario and elsewhere asking people to move to Alberta, and then get upset when lots of people come to Alberta. Nor do I understand how those arrivals can be blamed for the fact that our infrastructure and services, from schools to roads to hospitals, can not keep up with the influx.

It takes about 10 years to build a full-service hospital, and several years to recruit the staff for the new facility. Our UCP government has not built a new hospital in over a decade. Indeed, a couple of years ago they cancelled the only one in planning. They have also created all kinds of uncertainty about working conditions for any health-care professionals who might want to come to Alberta.

A woman sorts food items into cardboard boxes at a food bank, with text above advertising Vision Credit Union’s Helping Hand Grants, which offer up to $10,000 for rural Alberta non-profits, with a QR code and an application deadline of January 17, 2027.

Our shortages are not due to people moving to Alberta, but to a government that is allergic to planning for the easily foreseeable results of their policies.

And when there is a petition that opposes government ideas (see the Water Not Coal project), petitioners find an ever-expanding list of barriers erected. When the initial manoeuvres fail, the government suddenly finds “procedural” reasons to avoid putting the very clear position to a referendum.

If, on the other hand, you are pushing a position the government likes (see the separatists), all kinds of adjustments can be made to ensure the petition goes forward. And when progress is stalled by the inconvenient truth that the whole idea is unconstitutional, the blame is placed on the judge who read the law and said no. There is no blame for the petitioners or the government who failed at the most basic task of reading and following the legally defined route.

But none of that should be a surprise when the separatists’ lawyer has been in trouble with the Law Society several times. The same can be said of a government that seems to make a habit of appointing ministers of justice who run afoul of legal and ethical boundaries.

Overall, the impression one gets is of “rules for thee, but not for me.” Perhaps we should go for real change and elect representatives who actually represent the majority of voters, not the small group who are currently in power.

At least that is how I see it.

 

 


Shootin’ the Breeze welcomes your voice.

The Breeze Mailbox is a space for sharing thoughts, stories and conversations about what matters locally — from letters and opinion pieces to news releases and reader notes.

The views expressed here are personal and don’t necessarily reflect those of our team or ownership, but we believe in making space for respectful dialogue and community perspective.

Submission guidelines:

—Keep it under 800 words

—Include your full name and contact information

—Be respectful and constructive

We reserve the right to edit for clarity, length and tone.

Have something to share? We’d love to hear from you. Send your submission to publisher@shootinthebreeze.ca.

Alberta Independence | Separation, Citizen Initiative Petitions, Elections | Referendums, opinion, Water Not Coal Petition