Skip to main content
Lundbreck residents are advocating for reduced speed limits on Highway 3 after the Municipal District of Pincher Creek council rejected their request for signs advising truckers to limit the use of engine retarder brakes. Led by Larry Whan, the community has voiced concerns over highway noise and safety, citing the constant disruption caused by trucks.
IMAGE: Image as presented in the agenda package for MD of Pincher Creek council’s Sept. 10 meeting
A view of the stretch of road where Lundbreck residents sought to install signs advising truckers to avoid using engine retarder brakes. Their request was denied, leading to a push for reduced speed limits to improve safety and reduce noise.

Lundbreck residents focus on speed limit reduction after MD council rejects brake sign

September 14, 2024
Somya Lohia

Lundbreck residents are planning to approach Alberta Transportation to explore options for reducing the speed limit on Highway 3. The step has been planned to address their concerns about highway noise and safety, after their request of placing Truckers: Please Avoid the Use of Engine Retarder Brakes signage was declined by the Municipal District of Pincher Creek. On Sept. 10, the motion to apply to Alberta Transportation for the sign was defeated in the MD council meeting.

Larry Whan, who has been leading the effort, has lived in Lundbreck since 2009. For over a decade, he considered the noise from trucks using engine retarder brakes as a normal part of living near a highway. “For 15 years, I assumed the trucks going down the hill and using their brakes was the cost of doing business. I bought a house on the river, across from the highway, and I just figured, that’s part of it,” he told Shootin’ the Breeze.

 

Also read | Town council approves renewal of dangerous goods route bylaw, excludes Pronghorn Avenue

 

However, during a trip to Cochrane, Whan noticed a sign that read, Truckers: Please Avoid the Use of Engine Retarder Brakes, positioned at the bottom of a steep hill. This struck him as a potential solution for Lundbreck. “The hill in Cochrane is much steeper and longer, and they still had the sign,” he said. “I thought if they can ask truckers there, why can’t we have something similar here?”

Whan initially contacted Alberta Transportation, where he learned the process for such signage required the local MD to apply. “I spoke to a gentleman named Kenneth Mulhal from Alberta Transportation, and he told me the application has to be made by the MD since they would bear the cost of the sign. It’s about $3,000, and they want the MD to be aware of the expense,” Whan said.

With this information, Whan approached administration at the MD of Pincher Creek, requesting that they apply for a sign on behalf of Lundbreck residents. “The administration assured me that it would be added to the council agenda,” he recalled.

On Dec. 12, 2023, council denied the request due to safety concerns. “I was told that it was an unappealable decision. That didn’t sit right with me,” Whan said.

When he inquired further, he was informed that he could return as a delegation to present his case again.

Over the next four months, he gathered signatures and support from other Lundbreck residents, forming a delegation of 25 to 30 people to push for the sign.

At the June 25, 2024, council committee meeting, Whan presented the delegation of residents, laying out their concerns and providing documentation to back their request for an engine retarder brake sign. “It felt like they were determined not to let it go through. I was there to talk about why we needed the sign, but I found myself defending traffic safety for Alberta Transportation — a topic I’m not an expert on,” he said.

Whan said his objective was simple: get the MD to make an application to Alberta Transportation for the sign. He wasn’t asking for a definitive answer on whether the sign would be installed—that decision rested solely with Alberta Transportation. “All the MD had to do was apply,” he said. “Alberta Transportation would then decide if it was safe or not.”

 

Also read | Crowsnest Pass Council passes controversial lot rezoning bylaw amid residents’ opposition

 

After his presentation, MD council took time to deliberate.

On July 9, council again took up the issue in the presence of Whan’s delegation. Following a debate, the motion was defeated after a 2-2 tie.

“So unfortunately, it did not get approved,” Whan said.

In the Aug. 27 meeting, Coun. John MacGarva brought the engine retarder brake sign issue back to council’s agenda for the third time. After a discussion, council postponed the matter to a later meeting, in order to gather more information from Alberta Transportation.

Whan expressed his frustration over the delay, explaining that Alberta Transportation had specific guidelines for the sign, which the MD of Pincher Creek had already been provided.

“They tabled the meeting so that they could go to Alberta Transportation and get the document called the Recommended Practices for the sign,” Whan said.

“In November 2023, I sent this exact same package to the administration in the MD of Pincher Creek.”

In response to council’s request for more information, Alberta Transportation provided clarification regarding the engine retarder brake sign process. According to Alberta Transportation, “These signs are a courtesy, not regulatory.”

It emphasized that the local municipality must bear the installation cost as the signs serve a municipal rather than highway operation purpose. The Technical Evaluation Committee stated it would support whatever decision the local council made, whether to install or not install the sign, with the condition that signs would need to be installed in both directions on Highway 3.

Alberta Transportation’s stance gave the MD of Pincher Creek the final say, should it decide to bear the costs on behalf of its ratepayers.

In the Sept. 10 meeting, discussions around placing the engine retarder brake sign intensified.

Coun. MacGarva emphasized the broad community backing, stating, “We have got over 50 ratepayers that are in support of this.”

Coun. Tony Bruder added a critical perspective on the safety of people, asserting, “This is a safety concern. Comparing it to Cochrane and other places, this would be the only sign at 100 kilometres and that intersection which is right at the bottom of the hill. It’s a safety issue.”

CAO Roland Milligan cautioned about the implications of installing such a sign, stating, “There is a section in the Recommended Practices by Alberta Transportation about possible safety concerns, which indicates that action restricting the use of engine retarder brakes may have legal and safety implications.

“Since truck drivers often rely on engine brakes to control their vehicles under various situations, signs advising truck drivers to limit the use of engine brakes will normally be discouraged.”

Following these considerations, the motion for the engine retarder brake sign was ultimately defeated.

Undeterred, the residents are now planning to approach Alberta Transportation directly, exploring options to reduce the speed limit on the hill.

Whan explained, “One of the big concerns in the meeting was how fast trucks come down the hill. A councillor mentioned that this might be the only hill in Alberta where trucks travel at 100 kilometres per hour.”

He continued, “We’re questioning why the speed limit is set at 100 kilometres per hour at an intersection leading into Lundbreck. Our goal is to request a speed reduction to 70 kilometres per hour, starting half a kilometre east of the Lundbreck entrance and extending it down the hill. This change could help reduce speed-related concerns and enhance safety at the intersection, which is currently very dangerous.”

Whan also noted, “In Cochrane, after a major accident, they reduced the speed limit on a similar hill to 50 kilometres per hour, which Alberta Transportation approved. This shows they can adjust speed limits based on traffic conditions and safety needs.”

He acknowledged that while noise pollution may never be fully eliminated, reducing the speed limit could significantly help. “The noise from trucks is constant and persistent,” he said. “We’re trying to minimize it as much as possible for the residents here.”

Whan is now working to make an application to Alberta Transportation and plans to seek support from MLA Chelsea Petrovic, aiming to address the safety and noise concerns by adjusting the speed limit on the hill.

Another Lundbreck resident, Daren Dunbar, echoed Whan’s approach of reducing the speed limit.

“I will be a part of it. I think that is a good common-sense thing. I think that’s an intersection where people should be slowing down,” he said.

Read more Pincher Creek, Crowsnest Pass and area news here

 

 

Event poster for a Secondhand Dreamcar concert at the Empress Theatre on November 20, 2026, at 7:30 PM, featuring a photo of the band members.
A banner promoting local journalism in Canada, highlighting Shoot the Breeze’s community-focused reporting, partners, government funding, awards, and the Alberta Weekly Newspapers Association logo.
Leave a Reply

Southwest Alberta News, Features and Events

Ascent Dental banner with logo, dentist names, and a smiling family of four. Text reads “Trusted, experienced and friendly dental care for the whole family!” and “View Services” button.
Lundbreck residents are advocating for reduced speed limits on Highway 3 after the Municipal District of Pincher Creek council rejected their request for signs advising truckers to limit the use of engine retarder brakes. Led by Larry Whan, the community has voiced concerns over highway noise and safety, citing the constant disruption caused by trucks.
IMAGE: Image as presented in the agenda package for MD of Pincher Creek council’s Sept. 10 meeting
A view of the stretch of road where Lundbreck residents sought to install signs advising truckers to avoid using engine retarder brakes. Their request was denied, leading to a push for reduced speed limits to improve safety and reduce noise.

Lundbreck residents focus on speed limit reduction after MD council rejects brake sign

September 14, 2024
Somya Lohia

Lundbreck residents are planning to approach Alberta Transportation to explore options for reducing the speed limit on Highway 3. The step has been planned to address their concerns about highway noise and safety, after their request of placing Truckers: Please Avoid the Use of Engine Retarder Brakes signage was declined by the Municipal District of Pincher Creek. On Sept. 10, the motion to apply to Alberta Transportation for the sign was defeated in the MD council meeting.

Larry Whan, who has been leading the effort, has lived in Lundbreck since 2009. For over a decade, he considered the noise from trucks using engine retarder brakes as a normal part of living near a highway. “For 15 years, I assumed the trucks going down the hill and using their brakes was the cost of doing business. I bought a house on the river, across from the highway, and I just figured, that’s part of it,” he told Shootin’ the Breeze.

 

Also read | Town council approves renewal of dangerous goods route bylaw, excludes Pronghorn Avenue

 

However, during a trip to Cochrane, Whan noticed a sign that read, Truckers: Please Avoid the Use of Engine Retarder Brakes, positioned at the bottom of a steep hill. This struck him as a potential solution for Lundbreck. “The hill in Cochrane is much steeper and longer, and they still had the sign,” he said. “I thought if they can ask truckers there, why can’t we have something similar here?”

Whan initially contacted Alberta Transportation, where he learned the process for such signage required the local MD to apply. “I spoke to a gentleman named Kenneth Mulhal from Alberta Transportation, and he told me the application has to be made by the MD since they would bear the cost of the sign. It’s about $3,000, and they want the MD to be aware of the expense,” Whan said.

With this information, Whan approached administration at the MD of Pincher Creek, requesting that they apply for a sign on behalf of Lundbreck residents. “The administration assured me that it would be added to the council agenda,” he recalled.

On Dec. 12, 2023, council denied the request due to safety concerns. “I was told that it was an unappealable decision. That didn’t sit right with me,” Whan said.

When he inquired further, he was informed that he could return as a delegation to present his case again.

Over the next four months, he gathered signatures and support from other Lundbreck residents, forming a delegation of 25 to 30 people to push for the sign.

At the June 25, 2024, council committee meeting, Whan presented the delegation of residents, laying out their concerns and providing documentation to back their request for an engine retarder brake sign. “It felt like they were determined not to let it go through. I was there to talk about why we needed the sign, but I found myself defending traffic safety for Alberta Transportation — a topic I’m not an expert on,” he said.

Whan said his objective was simple: get the MD to make an application to Alberta Transportation for the sign. He wasn’t asking for a definitive answer on whether the sign would be installed—that decision rested solely with Alberta Transportation. “All the MD had to do was apply,” he said. “Alberta Transportation would then decide if it was safe or not.”

 

Also read | Crowsnest Pass Council passes controversial lot rezoning bylaw amid residents’ opposition

 

After his presentation, MD council took time to deliberate.

On July 9, council again took up the issue in the presence of Whan’s delegation. Following a debate, the motion was defeated after a 2-2 tie.

“So unfortunately, it did not get approved,” Whan said.

In the Aug. 27 meeting, Coun. John MacGarva brought the engine retarder brake sign issue back to council’s agenda for the third time. After a discussion, council postponed the matter to a later meeting, in order to gather more information from Alberta Transportation.

Whan expressed his frustration over the delay, explaining that Alberta Transportation had specific guidelines for the sign, which the MD of Pincher Creek had already been provided.

“They tabled the meeting so that they could go to Alberta Transportation and get the document called the Recommended Practices for the sign,” Whan said.

“In November 2023, I sent this exact same package to the administration in the MD of Pincher Creek.”

In response to council’s request for more information, Alberta Transportation provided clarification regarding the engine retarder brake sign process. According to Alberta Transportation, “These signs are a courtesy, not regulatory.”

It emphasized that the local municipality must bear the installation cost as the signs serve a municipal rather than highway operation purpose. The Technical Evaluation Committee stated it would support whatever decision the local council made, whether to install or not install the sign, with the condition that signs would need to be installed in both directions on Highway 3.

Alberta Transportation’s stance gave the MD of Pincher Creek the final say, should it decide to bear the costs on behalf of its ratepayers.

In the Sept. 10 meeting, discussions around placing the engine retarder brake sign intensified.

Coun. MacGarva emphasized the broad community backing, stating, “We have got over 50 ratepayers that are in support of this.”

Coun. Tony Bruder added a critical perspective on the safety of people, asserting, “This is a safety concern. Comparing it to Cochrane and other places, this would be the only sign at 100 kilometres and that intersection which is right at the bottom of the hill. It’s a safety issue.”

CAO Roland Milligan cautioned about the implications of installing such a sign, stating, “There is a section in the Recommended Practices by Alberta Transportation about possible safety concerns, which indicates that action restricting the use of engine retarder brakes may have legal and safety implications.

“Since truck drivers often rely on engine brakes to control their vehicles under various situations, signs advising truck drivers to limit the use of engine brakes will normally be discouraged.”

Following these considerations, the motion for the engine retarder brake sign was ultimately defeated.

Undeterred, the residents are now planning to approach Alberta Transportation directly, exploring options to reduce the speed limit on the hill.

Whan explained, “One of the big concerns in the meeting was how fast trucks come down the hill. A councillor mentioned that this might be the only hill in Alberta where trucks travel at 100 kilometres per hour.”

He continued, “We’re questioning why the speed limit is set at 100 kilometres per hour at an intersection leading into Lundbreck. Our goal is to request a speed reduction to 70 kilometres per hour, starting half a kilometre east of the Lundbreck entrance and extending it down the hill. This change could help reduce speed-related concerns and enhance safety at the intersection, which is currently very dangerous.”

Whan also noted, “In Cochrane, after a major accident, they reduced the speed limit on a similar hill to 50 kilometres per hour, which Alberta Transportation approved. This shows they can adjust speed limits based on traffic conditions and safety needs.”

He acknowledged that while noise pollution may never be fully eliminated, reducing the speed limit could significantly help. “The noise from trucks is constant and persistent,” he said. “We’re trying to minimize it as much as possible for the residents here.”

Whan is now working to make an application to Alberta Transportation and plans to seek support from MLA Chelsea Petrovic, aiming to address the safety and noise concerns by adjusting the speed limit on the hill.

Another Lundbreck resident, Daren Dunbar, echoed Whan’s approach of reducing the speed limit.

“I will be a part of it. I think that is a good common-sense thing. I think that’s an intersection where people should be slowing down,” he said.

Read more Pincher Creek, Crowsnest Pass and area news here

 

 

Announcement for Family Violence Prevention Month flag raising event on November 17 at 10 a.m. outside the Pincher Creek Library, hosted by the Pincher Creek Women’s Emergency Shelter Association.
Leave a Reply

Southwest Alberta News, Features and Events

Alberta and Beyond News, Features and Events

Job ad for “Shootin’ the Breeze” seeks part-time and full-time staff for photography, writing, and reporting; contact publisher@shootinthebreeze.ca. Background shows printed news text and a hand holding a voice recorder.
Shootin' the Breeze connection to more local stories