Skip to main content

Location: Clearwater County

Gavel rests on sounding block on a table.

Water Not Coal asks court to overturn petition ruling

The fight over coal mining near the headwaters of the Oldman River is headed to court. Corb Lund‘s Water Not Coal campaign has asked a judge to overturn Elections Alberta‘s decision that its petition, signed by more than 200,000 Albertans, fell just short of forcing a referendum.

One of the two projects the petition targeted is Northback Holdings’ Grassy Mountain, near the Oldman headwaters in the Crowsnest Pass. The other is Valory Resources’ Blackstone project in Clearwater County, near the headwaters of the North Saskatchewan River.

The campaign filed its application for judicial review July 29 in the Alberta Court of King’s Bench, on behalf of initiative proponent Lund. It argues Elections Alberta applied verification standards stricter than the Citizen Initiative Act requires, wrongly excluding thousands of valid signatures.

The application asks the court to declare the initiative successful or, failing that, send it back to Elections Alberta for reconsideration.

“More than 200,000 Albertans signed this petition in good faith, and they deserve a fair and reasonable process,” Lund said in a statement.

“Thousands of Albertans were effectively shut out by verification processes that don’t make sense. This judicial review is about ensuring that citizens’ voices weren’t lost in technicalities.”

How the count fell short

Water Not Coal submitted 207,435 signatures to Elections Alberta on June 10. An initial count validated 196,088 — well above the 177,732 needed to force a referendum.

A second-stage verification, conducted from June 11 to July 2, dropped that number to 172,088, leaving the campaign 5,644 signatures short. It was the first citizen initiative petition verified with scrutineers present, a change introduced through Bill 23, the Justice Statutes Amendment Act, 2026.

Ace of spades card on ad for Chase the Ace at the Pincher Creek Legion

What the application alleges

The judicial review application raises several concerns about how Elections Alberta carried out its verification.

On the legal standard, it points to sections 4 and 6 of the Citizen Initiative Act, arguing the chief electoral officer demanded more than the legislation sets out and undermined its purpose of encouraging public participation in direct democracy.

On the verification calls, the application says the process required electors to recall precise details from a petition they may have signed months earlier, with limited opportunity to clarify their answers.

It also says the calls did not display “Elections Alberta” in caller ID as previously indicated and questions whether the agency considered the recent electors-list data breach and its possible effect on response rates.

On the statistical side, the application challenges the five per cent margin of error and the sampling method, arguing the process failed to account for uncertainty in small sample sizes, applied the mid-point of a formula rather than its low-point, and replaced non-responding electors too quickly.

Together, the campaign says, those practices rejected too many signatures and accepted too few.

The petition and how it got here

The petition, formally titled No New Coal Mining in the Eastern Slopes of the Rocky Mountains, sought to prohibit new coal exploration and mining in the region, exempting mines already in active production as of Jan. 1, 2026.

The campaign began after Elections Alberta issued a notice of initiative petition Feb. 10. Signature collection ran until June 10, when Lund and supporters delivered 18 bins of petition sheets to Elections Alberta’s Edmonton office in a horse trailer.

Event poster for a Secondhand Dreamcar concert at the Empress Theatre on November 20, 2026, at 7:30 PM, featuring a photo of the band members.

Elections Alberta’s response

As of publication, Elections Alberta had not publicly responded to the judicial review application. In an earlier written response to Shootin’ the Breeze on the caller-ID concerns, however, the agency said caller ID displaying “Elections AB” was active during verification, and that testing confirmed it worked as intended.

Some recipients may not have seen the identification, the agency said. Individual telephone companies may not include caller ID in their registries and some recipients may have had spam-blocking or caller ID settings that hid it.

Electors selected for verification received a text message before a verification phone call, if they had provided a phone number, the agency said. If a call went unanswered, staff left a voice mail explaining its purpose, a callback number and the verification questions.

Electors who provided an email instead received a message asking them to verify their petition information.

“No signatures were deemed invalid or failed verification because an elector did not answer a phone call or respond to an email or voice mail,” the agency said.

Citizen Initiative Act, Citizen Initiative Petitions, Coal Mining, Eastern Slopes, Elections | Referendums, Judicial Review, Petition Verification, Water Protection

Corb Lund, man with dark hair wearing a cowboy hat with crowd behind him

Lund weighs legal action after coal petition fails

The Water Not Coal campaign says it submitted more than enough signatures to force a referendum on new coal mining in Alberta’s Eastern Slopes, but Elections Alberta says it missed the mark by 5,644. Now proponent Corb Lund is exploring a court challenge over how the count came up short.

In a statement issued July 6 Lund says he has concerns about the “procedural fairness” of Elections Alberta’s validation and verification process and is consulting lawyers over whether it was applied reasonably.

Of 207,435 signatures submitted, the agency validated 196,088 — comfortably above the 177,732 required under Alberta’s Citizen Initiative Act. But a verification step that involved contacting a sample of signatories by phone and email reduced the estimated number of valid signatures to 172,088, leaving the campaign short.

Lund has concerns about the number of signatures removed during the process.

“In the end, 35,000 of 207,000 signatories were rejected for various reasons. This seems like a ridiculously large number, given the thoroughness and dedication of our canvassers,” he says. “After being briefed by my lawyer/scrutineer that was in the room during the count, I have some real issues with the way this was handled.”

He says Albertans made their opposition to coal development clear and the government should not allow “thousands of Albertans” to be disenfranchised. He and his team have 30 days to file for a judicial review and are weighing their options.

Lund says the provincial government should recognize the 172,088 verified signatures and pause coal development in the Eastern Slopes.

“That’s 10 per cent of actual voters from the last election,” he says. “The overwhelming voices of Albertans opposing development in these areas needs to be respected.”

A woman sorts food items into cardboard boxes at a food bank, with text above advertising Vision Credit Union’s Helping Hand Grants, which offer up to $10,000 for rural Alberta non-profits, with a QR code and an application deadline of January 17, 2027.

Water Not Coal director Laura Laing defended the campaign’s canvassers.

“We had 196,088 validated signatures, meaning there was only a five per cent error rate in the signature sheets submitted by our volunteer canvassers. In a complex and detailed process, this reflects exceptional integrity and professional accountability,” she says.

“They are understandably exasperated by the announcement.”

Lund says he is now “up to his eyeballs in meetings with attorneys specializing in administrative law.”

Next steps for Water Not Coal are expected in the days ahead.

Reaction in the region is split

The outcome landed differently among locals, in a region long divided over coal development.

Allan Garbutt, a Cowley resident who supports the petition, is unhappy with the result. He questions whether the verification process was fair to signatories, not the campaign.

“I don’t think there was a lack of signatures,” he says. “I think it’s a difficult verification process.”

Get Stuff’d meat and seafood shop sign, located at 214 13th St. in Fort Macleod, open Thursday through Saturday from 12 noon to 6 p.m., phone 368-996-1968, follow us on Facebook at Get Stuff’d.

“This day and age, who picks up the phone for an unknown caller? A whole lot of email gets directed straight to junk. I suspect that had a lot to do with Elections Alberta not being able to verify some signatures.”

Garbutt trusts Lund and Water Not Coal to navigate the legal process ahead.

Pincher Creek resident Don McRae takes the opposite view. He is “very pleased” with the announcement, saying modern regulations already protect water sources from mining impacts.

“I believe the environmental guidelines today make companies more accountable to ensure water is not harmed,” he says. “I believe the southwest corner of Alberta needs an industry like Grassy Mountain to bring economic development to our area.”

McRae says the province should work with the federal government to keep environmental standards in place while approving development.

“Our younger generation needs some good-paying careers so they stay and raise families in our communities,” he says.

How the count worked

The 177, 732 threshold represents 10 per cent of the voters who cast ballots in Alberta’s 2023 provincial election.

Elections Alberta says signatures were most often removed during validation for errors in elector information, missing information, duplicate entries — 551 in all — and incomplete canvasser declarations.

Job ad for “Shootin’ the Breeze” seeks part-time and full-time staff for photography, writing, and reporting; contact publisher@shootinthebreeze.ca. Background shows printed news text and a hand holding a voice recorder.

The verification process, which reduced the total further, involved contacting a random sample of petition signatories by phone and email to confirm their information. This reduced the estimated number of valid signatures to 172,088.

The agency also checked the petition against seeded names as an anti-fraud measure and found none among the submitted signatures.

Background

The petition, formally titled No New Coal Mining in the Eastern Slopes of the Rocky Mountains, sought to prohibit new coal mining and exploration. It would have exempted mines already in active production as of Jan. 1, 2026.

Two projects were named directly. One is Northback Holdings’ Grassy Mountain project near the headwaters of the Oldman River in the Crowsnest Pass. The other is Valory Resources‘ Blackstone project in Clearwater County, near the headwaters of the North Saskatchewan River.

Grassy Mountain has a contentious history. A joint federal-provincial review panel rejected the project in 2021, when it was held by Benga Mining. It later returned to the approval process under Northback Holdings. In May 2025, the Alberta Energy Regulator approved deep-drilling exploration permits for the site.

The petition campaign launched with the issuance of a notice of initiative petition on Feb. 10. Signature collection ran until June 10. Lund and Water Not Coal supporters delivered 18 bins of signature sheets to the Elections Alberta office in Edmonton, unloading them from a horse trailer.

Verification began June 11 and concluded July 2, as required by regulations. It was the first citizen initiative petition verified with scrutineers present, a change introduced through Bill 23, the Justice Statutes Amendment Act, 2026.

Under the act, Lund and other proponents were required to return the petition and canvasser identification documents, destroy copies of signature sheets and file a signed affidavit confirming both steps by July 6.

Financial reports related to the campaign are due to Elections Alberta by Aug. 10.

Bill 23, Citizen Initiative Act, Coal Mining, Coal Policy, No New Coal Mining Petition, Resource Development, Water Security

Blank petition form with tip of fountain pen above signature line

Corb Lund’s coal petition fails by 5,644 signatures

A citizen-led campaign aimed at stopping new coal mining along Alberta’s Eastern Slopes has failed to clear its final hurdle after a provincewide signature review.

Elections Alberta confirmed July 3 that the initiative led by musician Corb Lund and the Water Not Coal group is unsuccessful under the Citizen Initiative Act.

Chief Electoral Officer Gordon McClure said the petition did not meet the required threshold after verification and statistical sampling of signatures collected across the province.

Despite more than 196,000 signatures being counted as valid, the verified total fell below the legal requirement needed to trigger the proposed legislative change.

Under Alberta’s rules, a successful citizen initiative requires support from 10 per cent of voters who cast ballots in the most recent provincial election. That number was set at 177,732 signatures based on the 2023 general election.

Organizers appeared to clear that bar easily. Elections Alberta reported that 196,088 signatures were initially counted as valid.

“There’ll be a few bad addresses, but we only needed 178,000. That’s a really big buffer. So we’re quite confident,” Lund told Shootin’ the Breeze after delivering the signatures to Elections Alberta.

However, after a required statistical sampling process applied at a 95 per cent confidence level, the estimated number of valid signatures dropped to 172,088, leaving the campaign 5,644 signatures short of the threshold.

Event flyer for The Hometown Holiday Market on November 14, 2026, at the Heritage Inn in Pincher Creek, featuring a list of vendors and event details set against a snowy holiday background.

In a statement issued July 3, Lund said he was “simultaneously shocked by this outcome, yet, unfortunately, not surprised, given the continual government rule changes and roadblocks we have faced throughout this campaign.”

He questioned both the result and the process behind it.

“This has been an unreasonable and opaque process from the beginning and, despite diligently following every rule, we are left with more questions than answers,” he said. “I have grave concerns about how this number was reached and the fairness of the process itself.”

Lund said his campaign delivered more than 205,000 signatures on June 10, of which roughly 35,000 were rejected. Elections Alberta’s count began from 196,088 signatures it initially deemed valid, which random statistical sampling then reduced to an estimated 172,088. The agency did not publish a figure for the total number of sheets delivered.

How the count worked

Provincewide, an estimated 5.8 per cent of Alberta’s roughly 2.96 million registered electors signed the petition, according to Elections Alberta.

The agency said most signatures rejected during the initial validation phase were tied to incomplete elector information, invalid dates, electors signing more than once and incomplete or improperly completed canvasser signature witnessing declarations.

During the verification phase, further signatures were lost. Some electors could not be reached and others were unwilling to confirm their information.

Elections Alberta also confirmed the petition was checked against seeded names drawn from the Republican Party of Alberta’s list of electors, an anti-fraud measure added May 1, 2026. No matches were found.

Announcement for Family Violence Prevention Month flag raising event on November 17 at 10 a.m. outside the Pincher Creek Library, hosted by the Pincher Creek Women’s Emergency Shelter Association.

The petition, formally titled the No New Coal Mining in the Eastern Slopes of the Rocky Mountains initiative, sought to prohibit new coal mining and exploration. It would have exempted mines already in active production as of Jan. 1, 2026.

Two projects were named directly. One is Northback Holdings’ Grassy Mountain project near the headwaters of the Oldman River in the Crowsnest Pass. The other is Valory Resources’ Blackstone project in Clearwater County, near the North Saskatchewan River’s headwaters.

Grassy Mountain has a contentious history. A joint federal-provincial review panel rejected the project in 2021, when it was held by Benga Mining. It later returned to the approval process under Northback Holdings. In May 2025, the Alberta Energy Regulator approved deep-drilling exploration permits for the site.

The petition campaign launched with the Notice of Initiative Petition on Feb. 10. Signature collection ran until June 10. Lund and Water Not Coal supporters delivered 18 bins of signature sheets to the Elections Alberta office in Edmonton, unloading them from a horse trailer.

Verification began June 11 and concluded July 2, as required under the Act. It was the first citizen initiative petition verified with scrutineers present, a change introduced through Bill 23, the Justice Statutes Amendment Act, 2026.

The process now moves to its final steps.

Under the Act, Lund and other proponents have until July 6 to return the petition and all canvasser identification documents to Elections Alberta, destroy any copies of signature sheets and file a signed affidavit confirming both steps were completed.

Financial reports related to the campaign are due to Elections Alberta by Aug. 10.

“Today’s announcement is merely another step in the overall fight to protect the Eastern Slopes, not the end of it,” Lund said. He will outline Water Not Coal’s next steps on Monday, July 6.

Bill 23, Citizen Initiative Act, Coal Mining, Coal Policy, No New Coal Mining Petition, Resource Development, Signature Verification, Water Security

Jim Green, a Pincher Creek supporter of Water Not Coal, stands with Corb Lund.

Coal petition delivered, premier says no October ballot

Corb Lund’s campaign to halt new coal mining along Alberta’s Eastern Slopes has cleared its threshold, but Premier Danielle Smith says the question won’t appear on the Oct. 19 referendum ballot, despite earlier indications it would.

On June 10, Lund and a group of Water Not Coal supporters unloaded 18 bins of signature sheets from a horse trailer outside the Elections Alberta office in Edmonton. Lund says organizers used the trailer to make a point about who this fight belongs to.

“We got over 205,000,” Lund told Shootin’ the Breeze. “There’ll be a few bad addresses, but we only needed 178,000. That’s a really big buffer. So we’re quite confident.”

Organizers say the four-month signature drive drew support from across the province — from urban centres to rural communities, First Nations and remote areas near the Eastern Slopes.

“It shows that Albertans are very strongly against these coal mines at the headwaters of our rivers,” Lund says. “We got signatures from 84 out of 87 ridings in the province. It was a very wide group of Albertans voicing their opinion.”

For Water Not Coal spokesperson Laura Laing, a rancher and longtime advocate for protecting the Eastern Slopes, the delivery was a milestone.

“It was very heartwarming,” she says. “We kind of wrapped all those months of blood, sweat and tears. It was quite the moment in history, really. One of the biggest moments that I think our province has seen on a grassroots initiative.”

Smith says deadline had already passed

On her June 13 Your Province, Your Premier radio show, Smith said the proposal is a legislative initiative that must be reviewed by a committee before recommendations are made to government.

Two men in high-visibility work shirts stand in a construction site above text that reads “Daventry Development’s share: $18,271,” followed by a summary of their business, the URL whatsyourshare.ca, and the Vision Credit Union logo.

During an unrelated press conference four days later, Smith told reporters the coal question will not appear on the Oct. 19 ballot. She said Elections Alberta set a June 1 deadline for the final list of referendum questions and the Water Not Coal verification process could not be completed in time.

Elections Alberta later confirmed to media that the deadline was set to ensure technological readiness, staffing and materials in advance of the referendum, saying each additional question requires 4.9 million ballot sheets.

Smith said the petition will instead be referred to a legislative committee, which will not be assembled until the legislature reconvenes Oct. 27.

“They’ll decide what direction to take with it,” she said. “It could result in a recommendation for a provincewide vote, which would take place in October of 2027.”

Smith also pointed to complications the committee would need to consider: provincial legislation requiring compensation when private property rights are restricted and the 2024 Crowsnest Pass plebiscite.

The premier’s announcement marks a shift from her earlier public position. As recently as April, she told reporters she expected the deadline for adding referendum questions to align with the close of the Water Not Coal signature-collection period.

Justice Minister Mickey Amery‘s office said the government plans “to see this process play out” and wait for the final verified signature count.

Lund disputes the deadline

Lund criticized the decision, saying organizers were not informed of the deadline despite discussions with the premier while the petition campaign was underway.

An older couple smiles while leaning on a wooden railing outdoors, above text describing their $879 profit share from Vision Credit Union and a website link.

“To be told that the petition won’t make the ballot because it allegedly missed a June 1 deadline is unacceptable,” Lund said in a statement following the premier’s comments.

“I personally met with the premier in her office on May 11. We were literally discussing the wording of my question as it should appear on the ballot, face-to-face. And at no point was any June 1 deadline mentioned.”

Smith repeatedly said publicly that if Water Not Coal collected enough signatures, the question would appear on the fall ballot, Lund said.

“My team, all the canvassers and Albertans in general deserve consistency, honesty and fair treatment around these petition and direct-democracy issues that the premier has professed to believe in so strongly, so many times.”

He also argued the government has the authority to add questions to the ballot if it chooses.

“If the premier wants to put something on the ballot, she easily can,” he said. “She has done so multiple times — first with her original nine referendum questions, and then with the current question on separatism. The authority and the choice are available to her. And Albertans deserve to know why that authority was not used in this case, despite more than 200,000 people calling for it.”

Lund also pointed to evidence beyond the petition itself.

“Independent findings from the coal policy review initiated by the former UCP government in 2021 showed more than 80 per cent of Albertans oppose new coal mining on the Eastern Slopes,” he said.

“Those facts, and the overwhelming public support reflected in more than 200,000 signatures, cannot be dismissed by a procedural excuse or an arbitrary deadline that was never communicated.”

On the Crowsnest Pass plebiscite Smith cited, Lund said the comparison was misleading.

“A turnout of roughly 1,700 people in a heavily lobbied local referendum in the Crowsnest Pass that voted in favour of the Grassy Mountain mining project (which is not even in the Crowsnest Pass municipality) does not represent the will of Albertans,” he said.

“More people canvassed for this petition than were even permitted to vote in the Crowsnest Pass plebiscite that the coal companies like to refer to so frequently. The scale of public concern is provincewide, and it cannot be minimized.”

What the petition asks

The petition calls on the provincial government to prohibit new coal mining and exploration anywhere along Alberta’s Eastern Slopes, exempting only mines already in active production as of Jan. 1, 2026.

It specifically names Northback Holdings‘ Grassy Mountain project near the headwaters of the Oldman River in the Crowsnest Pass area and Valory Resources’ Blackstone project in Clearwater County, near the headwaters of the North Saskatchewan River.

The Grassy Mountain proposal was rejected in 2021 by a joint federal-provincial review panel. Held at the time by Benga Mining, the project re-entered the approval process under Northback Holdings, and in May 2025 the Alberta Energy Regulator approved deep-drilling exploration permits.

Industry responds

Northback Holdings and Valory Resources both responded to the petition delivery with statements to CBC News on June 10. The Coal Association of Canada has also been a vocal industry voice during the campaign.

Northback’s strategic communications manager, James Robson, said there is strong support for the Grassy Mountain project “as demonstrated by provincewide external polling which determined that up to 74 per cent of Albertans support it.”

“Further, the 2024 referendum in Crowsnest Pass saw 72 per cent support for the Grassy Mountain project,” Robson wrote.

“If approved, the Grassy Mountain project will produce high-quality steelmaking coal for global markets, provide hundreds of millions of dollars in economic benefits and hundreds of direct jobs, while adhering to the highest environmental standards.”

Ian Black, CEO of Valory Resources, said in a written statement that his company is committed to developing its underground metallurgical coal mine responsibly.

“It is disappointing to see misinformation about this industry, especially in Alberta,” Black said.

Rina Blacklaws, vice-president of industry development for the Coal Association of Canada, told the Western Standard in early June that the petition would put project decisions in “the court of public opinion as opposed to the technical expert review panel at the Alberta Energy Regulator.”

“That can put our province at a disadvantage in attracting private sector investment and realizing the economic and community benefits that come with critical mineral development,” Blacklaws said.

Where things stand

Elections Alberta has until July 2 to complete signature verification.

Lund closed his statement with thanks to the campaign’s supporters:

“I want to thank every Albertan who signed, every volunteer who canvassed, and every community group that stood up to protect our water, mountains and ranchland. Your work matters. We will continue to organize, to demand accountability, transparency and to insist that promises made to the public are kept.”

Citizen-Led Petitions, Coal Mining, Coal Policy, Direct Democracy, Elections | Referendums, Environmental Protection, Public Accountability, Water Security

Corb Lund, man with dark hair wearing a cowboy hat with crowd behind him

Water Not Coal petition clears signature threshold

Corb Lund’s campaign to halt new coal mining along Alberta’s Eastern Slopes has cleared its threshold. Organizers delivered more than 205,000 signatures to Elections Alberta on June 10, about 27,000 more than the 177,732 signatures required under the Citizen Initiative Act.

Lund and a group of Water Not Coal supporters arrived at the Elections Alberta office in Edmonton with a horse trailer in tow. Eighteen bins of signature sheets were unloaded, marking what they describe as a defining moment in a six-year fight over coal policy in the province.

While Lund says there is a significant buffer between signatures required and collected, Elections Alberta must verify the signatures before the initiative can proceed further.

“We got over 205,000,” Lund says. “There’ll be a few bad addresses, but we only needed 178,000. That’s a really big buffer. So we’re quite confident.”

Organizers say the four-month signature drive drew support from across the province — from urban centres to rural communities, First Nations and remote areas near the Eastern Slopes.

“It shows that Albertans are very strongly against these coal mines at the headwaters of our rivers,” Lund says. “We got signatures from 84 out of 87 ridings in the province. It was a very wide group of Albertans voicing their opinion.”

For Water Not Coal organizers, the delivery marked both a logistical endpoint and an emotional milestone. Spokesperson Laura Laing, a rancher and longtime advocate for protecting the Eastern Slopes, calls the delivery a surreal and emotional moment.

“It was very heartwarming,” she says. “We kind of wrapped all those months of blood, sweat and tears. It was quite the moment in history, really. One of the biggest moments that I think our province has seen on a grassroots initiative.”

The horse trailer was a deliberate transportation choice. Lund says organizers brought it to make a point about who this fight belongs to.

“It was just to show people that rural people care about this,” he says.

Elections Alberta officials accepted the 18 bins, issued an affidavit of receipt and began verification the next morning. The agency, which operates independently of any political party, has 21 days to count and validate the signatures.

Clearing the threshold does not automatically put a coal question on a referendum ballot.

Under the Citizen Initiative Act, a verified legislative proposal goes to the Speaker of the legislative assembly and the government must refer it to a committee that can recommend either legislation or a provincewide vote.

Alberta already has a referendum with 10 separate questions set for Oct. 19; organizers hope a coal question can join it.

However, Premier Danielle Smith has indicated the coal proposal must first proceed through the process outlined in the Citizen Initiative Act before any decision is made on whether it will appear on a ballot.

Speaking on a radio show, Smith said the petition is a legislative proposal that must be reviewed by a committee, which will consult with government officials and make recommendations on how to proceed.

“I looked at the petition and it calls for a legislative proposal, so I have to figure out what that means,” Smith said. “There is a process that’s outlined in the act, and we will follow that process on this one too.”

What the petition asks

The petition calls on the provincial government to prohibit new coal mining and exploration anywhere along Alberta’s Eastern Slopes, exempting only mines already in active production as of Jan. 1, 2026.

It specifically names two proposed developments — Northback Holdings’ Grassy Mountain project near the headwaters of the Oldman River in the Crowsnest Pass area and Valory Resources’ Blackstone project in Clearwater County, near the headwaters of the North Saskatchewan River.

Lund has said both projects are at similar stages in the regulatory process and represent the most immediate potential coal developments on the Eastern Slopes, but has emphasized the petition is deliberately broader.

“We specifically included Grassy Mountain and Blackstone within the wording of the question, because we wanted to be very clear that it includes those two,” Lund has said.

Six years in the making

The campaign’s roots stretch back to 2020, when Alberta’s move to lift long-standing protections on Rocky Mountain coal mining sparked widespread opposition.

The Grassy Mountain proposal was rejected in 2021 by a joint federal-provincial review panel, when the project was held by Benga Mining.

It re-entered the approval process with a modified approach under Northback Holdings rebranding and, in May 2025, the Alberta Energy Regulator approved deep-drilling exploration permits for the site.

Lund’s personal involvement includes meetings with coal lobbyists and company executives, correspondence with government ministers, participation in protests and presentations at regulatory hearings.

The idea for a citizen initiative took shape following a June 2025 town hall in Fort Macleod where Premier Smith encouraged those concerned about coal mining to consider that route. Lund and Water Not Coal organizers filed a notice of intent and received approval, but not without a significant setback.

Legislative interruption

In December 2025, the campaign was thrown into uncertainty when Elections Alberta informed organizers their previously approved petition had been retroactively cancelled following the implementation of Bill 14, provincial legislation that amended Alberta’s citizen initiative framework.

The bill transferred certain decision-making powers from the chief electoral officer to the justice minister and nullified petitions that had not been formally issued before the legislation took effect.

In a Dec. 12 statement, Lund said the cancellation was a serious blow but that organizers used the interruption to sharpen their operations. A new notice of intent was filed Dec. 19 and Elections Alberta confirmed on Jan. 27 that the revised application met legislative requirements.

The formal petition was issued Feb. 10, with the signature collection window running from Feb. 11 to June 10.

Four months on the road

Over the four-month collection period, Water Not Coal mobilized more than 3,000 registered canvassers across the province, staging thousands of signing events at community centres, markets, breweries, ranches, doorsteps and sidewalks.

In the final stretch, Lund conducted what organizers called a last-chance tour running from Lethbridge to Edmonton.

“There were people lined up to sign and say thanks,” Laing says, adding that even people from Crowsnest Pass and the MD of Ranchland supported the petition.

She says the broader human experience of the campaign left its own lasting impression.

“The friendships made along the way are incredible, and just connections to people we wouldn’t have met before,” Laing says. “I think the human experience of this whole thing has been the biggest adventure experience and return on our efforts for sure.”

Support for the campaign was also visible in the Pincher Creek area, which sits close to the proposed Grassy Mountain project. Lund says he received a “very positive” response during a visit to the community earlier in the campaign, noting it was his first time engaging directly with residents there on the coal issue.

A dispute over water

In the final weeks of the campaign, organizers seized on a Northback move they say validates their concerns — a water licence application Northback Holdings filed with the Alberta Energy Regulator. Organizers argue it contradicts the company’s years of assurances that Grassy Mountain would not need additional water from the already stressed Oldman River system.

“They promised for a number of years that they wouldn’t need any of our water, and they’ve just turned around and made an application for a large amount of water,” Lund says. “To me, that’s basically lying.”

Laing, whose ranch operations in southern Alberta have already been affected by drought and tightening water allocations, was equally pointed.

“They say one thing and do another once they’re in,” she says. “As a rancher in the south, I don’t know where this water is going to come from. On our ranch, we’ve had to divest our herd size to accommodate the lack of water. That water needs to be preserved. It’s our No. 1 resource in the province and we can’t be just giving that away.”

At a May 26 presentation to the MD of Pincher Creek council, Northback CEO Mike Young said the company revised its water approach to remove any direct withdrawal from creeks or streams. Instead, operational needs will be met with precipitation captured on-site and water recovered through mine dewatering, stored in dams during rain and seasonal freshet flows.

Young likened the model to storage systems used in Alberta’s irrigation networks and said a water allocation licence is required because the water would be stored and used.

Next steps and objectives

With the petition now in the hands of Elections Alberta, organizers say the next critical step will be determining wording for a potential referendum question. Lund is emphatic that the exact petition wording approved by Elections Alberta be used verbatim.

“We put a lot of time into the wording of our question with lawyers and a lot of thought,” he says. “We insist that the government use our exact wording, because we made it very specific to include the Blackstone project and the Grassy Mountain project.”

Looking beyond a vote, Lund describes a two-part vision of success — strong legislation banning new coal mining on the Eastern Slopes and a level of public awareness durable enough to outlast any future government.

“You could change legislation — even if they make good legislation, some other government can change it down the road,” he says.

“Our goal, in part, with the petition and referendum, is to get enough public discussion on this issue that most Albertans understand how bad an idea this is. If another politician comes along who’s fine with coal at the headwaters of our rivers, they’ll be run out of office.”

For now, organizers say they plan a brief rest before what they expect will be an intense lead-up to a possible fall vote and acknowledge the opposition won’t be quiet.

“The coal industry has become more and more aggressive in their attacks on us,” Lund says. “But they say if you’re getting flak, you’re over the target. They’re feeling the public pressure, definitely.”

 

Citizen Initiative Act, Coal Mining, Eastern Slopes, Elections | Referendums, Resource Development, Water Security